Before It’s Too Late – Part 2
(The friend of many years mentioned in the previous item has now died. That one can have had such a friend is a privilege. The thoughts below are an attempt to look at what lessons I can learn from his experience of dying, to honour a good man.)
Assisted dying. An enabled death, eased by choice. A death with lessened pain. A death with dignity. But assisting a death is illegal.
Often, it seems those that oppose assisted dying cite worse-case scenarios. For example, that the idea of assisted death starts off as an option, becomes a suggestion, then becomes an expectation. Yes, maybe that might arise. We don’t know – it’s all untested in the UK. (We should bear in mind that the experience of other nations might not be relevant – there are a lot of variables.) What we do know for sure is that lives ending with final weeks, months or longer in pain, often stripped of dignity, are already happening in the UK. And they are ending in this way because no-one’s allowed to assist the dying to die.
And we can also all be sure that without change this grim truth will persist.
Who can help? My own limited personal experience tells me that family doctors were once able to, quietly, sensibly, on a case-by-case basis. Now, at least according to some, they have been stripped of many of their options. ‘The Shipman case’ is cited as the reason why doctors are now unable to offer drugs that could prove fatal if over-consumed. But Shipman was a rare instance and, surely, we shouldn’t be governed by his despicable actions. But as things stand, it seems we are in effect ruled by one criminal and the bad law that’s resulted. And any number of innocent people have been rendered the victims.
Perhaps it varies, doctor-to-doctor; or if deaths occur in hospitals rather than at home. I don’t know. But whatever the realities on the ground, what’s actually wrong with assisted dying being an available choice?
Some say that people will opt for it so as to not become ‘a burden’ – on loved ones say, or on society. If that is the case – and that’s a big ‘if’ – that’s a choice people will be making. Who’s to say that’s the wrong choice?
If the drive to ‘not be a burden’ is rooted in pressure from family, friends or whoever, that’s one thing. It will need safeguarding against in any assisted dying legislation. If it’s rooted more generally, in ‘society’? Obviously, that would be a reflection both on society and on those that seek to set or influence its rules and attitudes. But why should this even arise, either at all or to any significant degree? What are the assumptions underlying these fears?
Everything else aside, discussion about the potential problems of assisted dying often omits the implications of the alternative. Do we want to live in a society that expects people to keep on living, regardless of their suffering, and regardless of their wishes? Who has the right to pressurize dying people to hang as long as possible, whatever the pain they are in, whether they want to live on or not? And who wants to live in a society where people promoting that attitude are in any way applauded?
Assisted dying would need safeguards and exclusions – for those not of ‘sound mind’ for example. But we also need the freedom to choose. And we also need access to the appropriate means to end our lives legally, with third-party help if it’s needed, if the release from pain that comes with death is the desired outcome.
Death will come to us all. To honour my friend, perhaps the best I can do is lobby to make an assisted death an achievable, accessible possibility for everyone who wants and needs it.
For Tony.
